Business valuation to determine share exchange ratios in a merger
For a cross-border merger, we valued both businesses to provide a basis for the share exchange ratio. Specific issues included currency risks and growth through acquisitions.
The intended acquiring company engaged us in an advisory capacity during the preparation of a cross-border merger by absorption to value both the transferring and acquiring entities. This was an inbound merger: the intended acquiring company was domiciled in Germany. The provisions of the German Transformation Act (Umwandlungsgesetz) were therefore relevant, particularly its tenth section, introduced in connection with the EC Cross-Border Mergers Directive.
The central valuation challenge was to reflect consistently the risk exposures of shareholders in the acquiring and transferring entities. In particular, the two companies were domiciled in different currency areas. Although common approaches in the literature to currency risk are pragmatic, they do not always fully serve the objective of value discovery, namely identifying the actual market value. A broad analysis of differences in risk between the two countries and currency areas was therefore required. By reflecting risk effects in both the numerator and denominator, while avoiding double counting, we were able to identify their effects in detail and present them transparently in the report for subsequent review.
A further issue was the analysis of certain intangible assets and their presentation in the two companies' balance sheets. A clear economic understanding of these items was essential to assessing the reasonableness of the financial plans and the underlying risk exposures. The main issue was the difference between the companies' historical growth strategies: organic growth in one case and acquisition-led growth in the other.
Key challenges
- Business valuations in an international context, particularly country risk
- Cost of capital techniques
- In-depth financial statement analysis
Experience and expertise
- More than 10 years of experience as a fundamental buy-side analyst covering companies and business models internationally
- Valuation expertise for complex cases, particularly demanding cost of capital questions
- More than 20 years of financial statement analysis experience, with membership of the IFRS Foundation's Capital Markets Advisory Committee and the EFRAG User Panel
References
- Meitner/Streitferdt (2014): Was sind Kapitalkosten? Eine integrierende Analyse, in: Corporate Finance, 12/2014, S. 527ff. [English title: What Is the Cost of Capital? An Integrated Analysis]
- Meitner/Streitferdt (2017), Die Ermittlung des sicheren Zinses in der Unternehmensbewertung, in: Die Wirtschaftsprüfung 2.2017, S. 98-104 . [English title: Determining the Risk-free Rate in Business Valuation]
- Meitner/Streitferdt (2023), Die Bestimmung des Beta-Faktors, in: Peemöller (Hrsg.), Praxishandbuch der Unternehmensbewertung, 8. Auflage, Herne et al., 2023, forthcoming. [English title: Determining Beta]
- Meitner/Streitferdt (2023), Sicherer Zins und Marktrisikoprämie, in: Peemöller (Hrsg.), Praxishandbuch der Unternehmensbewertung, 8. Auflage, Herne et al., 2023, forthcoming. [English title: The Risk-free Rate and Equity Risk Premium]
Presentations and seminars
- Düsseldorf, 10 November 2011: Country Risk and the Valuation of Foreign Cash Flows, EACVA Annual Conference
- Berlin, 6 December 2019: Current Trends in Financial Statement Analysis (for Business Valuators), EACVA Annual Conference
Further reading
Short videos
- Beta Basics: The Fundamentals of Our Favourite Risk Parameter (German)
- Why Take a Detour to Unlevered Beta When You Can Estimate It Directly? (German)
- Vasicek Adjustments: An Economic Perspective on Common Pitfalls (German)
- A Minor Dampener or a Major Distortion? Why Attenuation Is Not a Problem (German)
- The Equity Premium, An ongoing Puzzle
- Cosmetic or Consequential? The Equity Risk Premium and Inflation (German)

