Valuesque

Cases

Legal and statutory matters

Valuations for corporate law, tax, family law, inheritance, regulatory and financial reporting purposes.

Valuation context

Corporate law matters

Business valuation to determine share exchange ratios in a merger

For a cross-border merger, we valued both businesses to provide a basis for the share exchange ratio. Specific issues included currency risks and growth through acquisitions.

The intended acquiring company engaged us in an advisory capacity during the preparation of a cross-border merger by absorption to value both the transferring and acquiring entities. This was an inbound merger: the intended acquiring company was domiciled in Germany. The provisions of the German Transformation Act (Umwandlungsgesetz) were therefore relevant, particularly its tenth section, introduced in connection with the EC Cross-Border Mergers Directive.

The central valuation challenge was to reflect consistently the risk exposures of shareholders in the acquiring and transferring entities. In particular, the two companies were domiciled in different currency areas. Although common approaches in the literature to currency risk are pragmatic, they do not always fully serve the objective of value discovery, namely identifying the actual market value. A broad analysis of differences in risk between the two countries and currency areas was therefore required. By reflecting risk effects in both the numerator and denominator, while avoiding double counting, we were able to identify their effects in detail and present them transparently in the report for subsequent review.

A further issue was the analysis of certain intangible assets and their presentation in the two companies' balance sheets. A clear economic understanding of these items was essential to assessing the reasonableness of the financial plans and the underlying risk exposures. The main issue was the difference between the companies' historical growth strategies: organic growth in one case and acquisition-led growth in the other.

Key challenges

  • Business valuations in an international context, particularly country risk
  • Cost of capital techniques
  • In-depth financial statement analysis

Experience and expertise

  • More than 10 years of experience as a fundamental buy-side analyst covering companies and business models internationally
  • Valuation expertise for complex cases, particularly demanding cost of capital questions
  • More than 20 years of financial statement analysis experience, with membership of the IFRS Foundation's Capital Markets Advisory Committee and the EFRAG User Panel

References

  • Meitner/Streitferdt (2014): Was sind Kapitalkosten? Eine integrierende Analyse, in: Corporate Finance, 12/2014, S. 527ff. [English title: What Is the Cost of Capital? An Integrated Analysis]
  • Meitner/Streitferdt (2017), Die Ermittlung des sicheren Zinses in der Unternehmensbewertung, in: Die Wirtschaftsprüfung 2.2017, S. 98-104 . [English title: Determining the Risk-free Rate in Business Valuation]
  • Meitner/Streitferdt (2023), Die Bestimmung des Beta-Faktors, in: Peemöller (Hrsg.), Praxishandbuch der Unternehmensbewertung, 8. Auflage, Herne et al., 2023, forthcoming. [English title: Determining Beta]
  • Meitner/Streitferdt (2023), Sicherer Zins und Marktrisikoprämie, in: Peemöller (Hrsg.), Praxishandbuch der Unternehmensbewertung, 8. Auflage, Herne et al., 2023, forthcoming. [English title: The Risk-free Rate and Equity Risk Premium]

Presentations and seminars

  • Düsseldorf, 10 November 2011: Country Risk and the Valuation of Foreign Cash Flows, EACVA Annual Conference
  • Berlin, 6 December 2019: Current Trends in Financial Statement Analysis (for Business Valuators), EACVA Annual Conference

Our services Contact us About us

Advising minority shareholders in a squeeze-out and judicial appraisal proceedings

For minority shareholders, we reviewed the valuation in the squeeze-out of a listed company. The focus was on financial planning, cash flows and the cost of capital.

In the squeeze-out of a listed company with an equity market value of more than €20 billion, we critically reviewed the business valuations prepared by the appointed valuer and the court-appointed auditor on behalf of minority shareholders entitled to compensation. Our review covered the entire valuation framework: cash flow planning and its translation into forecasts, the cost of capital, model structure, cross-checking methods and other aspects.

Valuing large groups regularly requires the valuer to strike the right balance in simplifying complexity, maintain technical rigour despite that complexity, retain an economic perspective and assess the valuation as an integrated whole, taking account of interactions and weighing the relevant factors. These major projects therefore place high demands on valuers. It is unsurprising that valuation experts sometimes lose sight of the wider picture in parts of their work. Critical scrutiny of the approaches taken by the valuer and the auditor is consequently valuable.

Key challenges

  • In-depth examination of the cost of capital
  • Challenges in fundamental analysis
  • Integration of different business valuation perspectives

Experience and expertise

  • More than 10 years of experience as a fundamental buy-side analyst covering companies and business models internationally
  • Valuation expertise for complex cases, particularly demanding cost of capital questions
  • Regular seminar: Business Analysis, Cash Flow Forecasting and Assessment of Financial Plans, EACVA

References

  • Meitner/Streitferdt (2014): Was sind Kapitalkosten? Eine integrierende Analyse, in: Corporate Finance, 12/2014, S. 527ff. [English title: What Is the Cost of Capital? An Integrated Analysis]
  • Meitner/Streitferdt (2017), Die Ermittlung des sicheren Zinses in der Unternehmensbewertung, in: Die Wirtschaftsprüfung 2.2017, S. 98-104 . [English title: Determining the Risk-free Rate in Business Valuation]
  • Meitner/Streitferdt (2023), Die Bestimmung des Beta-Faktors, in: Peemöller (Hrsg.), Praxishandbuch der Unternehmensbewertung, 8. Auflage, Herne et al., 2023, forthcoming. [English title: Determining Beta]
  • Meitner/Streitferdt (2023), Sicherer Zins und Marktrisikoprämie, in: Peemöller (Hrsg.), Praxishandbuch der Unternehmensbewertung, 8. Auflage, Herne et al., 2023, forthcoming. [English title: The Risk-free Rate and Equity Risk Premium]

Our services Contact us About us

Valuation context

Tax matters

Business valuation as at 31 March 1999, the date of promulgation of the German Tax Relief Act (StEntlG)

A valuation for tax purposes required us to look back to 31 March 1999. With no financial plan from that period available, we reconstructed expectations using market, industry and company data.

In 2022, we were engaged to value a company founded in the early 1990s for tax purposes as at 31 March 1999. The background was that increases in the value of shareholdings arising before promulgation of the German Tax Relief Act (StEntlG) on 31 March 1999 were not subject to tax where the shareholding was not ‘substantial’ within the meaning of section 17(1), sentence 4 of the German Income Tax Act (EStG). Value increases generated up to that date were intended to remain tax-exempt. Only increases in the value of such shareholdings arising from 31 March 1999 onwards could therefore be subject to taxation. In 2022, the question arose as to the potential taxation of any increase in the company's value.

The complexity lay in reconstructing the analytical perspective at the valuation date. The valuation date principle requires consideration only of information that could have been obtained with reasonable care at that date (IDW S 1, paragraph 23). In the 1970s, the German Federal Court of Justice clarified its practical application through the ‘root theory’ (Wurzeltheorie, judgment of 17 January 1973, IV ZR 142/70). Under this principle, information obtained after the valuation date must be considered if it concerns an economic circumstance whose roots already existed before that date, known as information clarifying value. By contrast, later information must be excluded if it concerns a circumstance that arose only subsequently and had no roots at the valuation date, known as information creating value.

Reconstructing the appropriate information set for 1999, a notably dynamic year in the capital markets, required extensive fundamental analysis. There were no internal documents or management forecasts from which to model what had been expected, at that historical point, about the future. We therefore developed a comprehensive market, industry and company analysis, together with the forecasts derived from it. This provided the basis for the valuation.

Key challenges

  • Expertise in fundamental analysis
  • Rigorous research and use of sources
  • Estimation of cost of capital parameters specific to the valuation date

Experience and expertise

  • More than 10 years of experience as a fundamental buy-side analyst covering companies and business models internationally
  • Valuation expertise for complex cases, particularly demanding cost of capital questions
  • EACVA seminar: Business Analysis, Cash Flow Forecasting and Assessment of Financial Plans

Our services Contact us About us

Valuation context

Family law and inheritance matters

Business valuation for the equalisation of accrued gains on divorce

For the equalisation of accrued gains, we determined business values with limited information available. We took account of changes to the company and its relationship with its owner.

In divorce proceedings, one party engaged us to value the other party's shareholding. The information available in such cases is often limited. Despite disclosure obligations, data and information important to the valuation are frequently withheld or provided only in insufficient detail. This regularly requires our own analysis and research, often extending to the fundamentals of the business model. The research findings are then translated into quantitative forecasts and a risk assessment.

In this case, before the divorce, the other party had changed the company's structure and the relationship between the company and its shareholder with the aim of producing an apparent reduction in value. Alongside several more or less obvious changes, two familiar techniques were used: one sought to manipulate the company's cash flow generation, the other to alter the allocation of cash flows. Both are usually difficult for outsiders to identify.

We valued the company both before and after these structural changes. This gave our client a sound basis for the ensuing dispute.

Key challenges

  • Family law considerations, including the tax amortisation benefit and transferable earnings capacity
  • Fundamental analysis and cash flow forecasting
  • Identifying the effects of changes to corporate arrangements

Experience and expertise

  • More than 10 years of experience as a fundamental buy-side analyst covering companies and business models internationally
  • A firmly established fundamental analysis perspective in every valuation
  • Valuation expertise for complex cases

Our services Contact us About us

Valuation context

Financial reporting matters

Goodwill impairment test for a young company

We assessed the recoverability of goodwill at a young technology company. The key question was which future development activities could be reflected in the forecast under IAS 36.

We were engaged to determine the value in use of a young, research-intensive technology company for a goodwill impairment test under IFRS. A recurring issue when determining value in use is IAS 36.44: forecasts must reflect the asset in its current condition and must not anticipate future restructuring to which the entity is not yet committed, or expenditure to improve or enhance the asset's performance. Here, ‘the asset’ is the subject of the impairment test under IAS 36. It must therefore be valued in its existing condition.

This creates a particular dilemma for young companies. In their current condition, they are often unable to generate positive future cash flows. Future expenditure to improve or enhance performance is essential even to establish the viability of the business model. Technologies may need further development or efficiency improvements to become competitive. Research activities may need to progress and specific studies may still be required. Yet it is also clear that IAS 36 does not envisage assuming that an asset remains permanently unfinished. Defining the asset appropriately and determining the scope of the relevant cash flow forecasts, on a basis that can withstand audit scrutiny, are therefore fundamental.

Key challenges

  • Analysis of cash flow forecasts for young companies
  • Risk analysis for young companies

Experience and expertise

  • Extensive experience in start-up valuations
  • Valuation expertise for challenging cases, particularly complex cost of capital and risk assessment questions
  • EACVA seminar: Start-up Valuation, Analysis and Valuation of Young Companies and Innovative Business Models
  • EACVA seminar: Valuation of Data-Driven Business Models

References

  • Meitner (2021), Geschäftsmodelllogiken und Analyseansätze für das Asset „Daten“, Bewertungs-Praktiker 3/2021, S. 74-83. [English title: Business Models and Analytical Approaches for Data as an Asset]
  • Meitner/Prengel/Kunitz (2023) Bewertung von Start-ups und innovativen Geschäftsideen, in: Peemöller (Hrsg.), Praxishandbuch der Unternehmensbewertung, 8. Auflage, Herne et al. 2023, forthcoming. [English title: Valuing Start-ups and Innovative Business Ideas]

Presentations and seminars

  • 27 May 2019: The Valuation of Young Tech Companies, annual conference, Nederlands Instituut voor Register Valuators, Eindhoven

Our services Contact us About us

All cases

Contact

Let's discuss your case.

Message Valuesque