Valuesque

3 January 2019 · General · Matthias Meitner

Four Interesting Insights into Business Valuation, Collected at the EACVA Conference on 22–23 November 2018

The annual EACVA business valuation conference (www.bewerterkonferenz.de) is the leading forum in the German-speaking world for exchanging new valuation insights. See also my presentation at the 12th Annual EACVA Conference. These exchanges take place not only in presentations and the sometimes heated discussions that follow, but also over coffee, evening drinks or a ride in the lift. Often, the most revealing conversations are one-to-one. Here are my four main insights from the 2018 conference:

  • Participants focused on valuations for investment or corporate decision-making increasingly struggle to follow the ever more detailed developments in valuation for accounting and legal purposes. These parallel worlds have existed for some time. More troubling is that communication between them appears to be weakening. As one experienced investment professional told me, expert valuers had still been interested in his investment thinking three years earlier, whereas now they increasingly volunteered explanations of how his own business ought to work.
  • I repeatedly received questions about succession and valuation, all concerning immediate problems. How should family disagreements over value be handled? How should the former owner’s emotional attachment be reflected? What value might have been realised if succession had been planned earlier? The central question was rarely asked, in fact only once: what should a succession process look like if the aim is to maximise value?
  • Auditors may find it difficult to escape some of the problems they have created without losing face. During an enjoyable lunch, the discussion again turned to personal income taxes. For decades, IDW S 1 and the auditors’ handbook have applied more or less well-calibrated valuation models with an implied level of precision that sits uneasily with uncertainty in forecasts and discount rates. A leading figure in valuation for legal purposes offered a memorable analogy: IDW S 1 was like a pinball machine with the income-tax ball stuck at the top. However hard auditors shook the machine, they could not dislodge it.
  • Distressed valuation, meaning valuation during crisis and insolvency, occupied far more of my conversations than in previous years. That was interesting in itself, since we had discussed it relatively little for some time. I also regard it as a potentially strong early indicator of the valuation environment ahead.

Contact

Let's discuss your case.

Message Valuesque